Want to save this recipe?
We'll email this recipe to you, so you can come back to it later!
I don’t have kids in the traditional sense, but I do have Brody (and the cats). And as my Granny likes to say, Brody thinks he is my baby. Considering how spoiled he is, it isn’t much of a surprise.
Jorge and I got Brody very early in our relationship. Brody was 4 months old and had ears that were bigger than him. After looking at his paperwork, we discovered that Brody was actually born on our first date and that his mother was named Driving Miss Daisy.
At the time that was my nickname. I was driving around in a big white Cadillac DeVille. If you don’t know much about Cadillacs — it’s the land yacht of cars and couldn’t fit in a normal parking spot. Plus, I’m pretty sure no one under 50 drives them (I was 19 at the time). I thankfully only had to drive it for a couple of months, but the name stuck.
We like to think that Brody was destined to be ours…and here we are 7 years later and I’m still spoiling him rotten.
This is my third version of treats I have made just for Brody. He is a fool for peanut butter. You can not even open up the jar without him loosing his mind! So while I have made three different treats…they are all peanut butter! You have the Peanut Butter & Oat Bones with Frosting & Sprinkles, the Banana Peanut Butter Cookie and now these Peanut Butter Sandwiched Dog Treats.
I made these with the dog treats you find at Petco in mind. You know the ones they have in those buffet style treat bins? They make these sandwich peanut butter cookies that Brody goes gaga over. I figured I could make something similar, but for a lot less money. By the way he has been gulping these down, I think they are a major success!
Peanut Butter Sandwiched Dog Treats
Ingredients
- 1 ¼ cup flour, plus a little extra for cutting dough
- ½ teaspoon baking powder
- ½ cup creamy peanut butter
- 1 large egg
- 2 tablespoons honey
- ½ cup milk
- additional peanut butter for sandwiching
Want to save this recipe?
We'll email this recipe to you, so you can come back to it later!
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350°F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper, set aside.
- In a large bowl (or stand mixer), combine all ingredients, beating until a soft dough forms.
- Dust counter with flour. Pat out dough into a large rectangle, about 1 inch in depth. Using a 1 1/2 inch circle shaped cookie cutter, cut into circles. Use all dough.
- Bake for 10 to 12 minutes, or until they are a uniform color on top (as they bake, the color will actually lighten instead of darken). Transfer to a wire rack and let cool completely.
- When your pup deserves a treat, smear a little peanut butter in the center of two cookies and sandwich them together!
- I store these cookies without the peanut butter in the center. Then when I want to give Brody a treat, I put some fresh peanut butter in the center and sandwich the cookies together right before I hand it to him. The treats stay fresh for much longer this way (up to 2 weeks).
Nutrition
Categories:
Post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.
Most know of this, however, a few may not be aware of the dangers of xylitol or artificial sweeteners in some peanut and nut butters, which can be fatal for our furry family members. These look amazing by the way!
❤️
Are you storing these on the counter in an air tight container or in the fridge?
Hi Julie! Store them at room temperature for up to 5 days. You can also refrigerate them in an airtight container to store for up to 7 days. Or freeze them! I freeze the cookies with the peanut butter in the middle for months. My dogs love them frozen or thawed!
Thank you for this! I’m going to make these cookies for my spoiled Schnoodle puppy Sonny that’s turning one next month. His friends at daycare will love them!! I think I’m going to try a cream cheese doggie frosting so it can be colored to make them look even more like macaroons. Thank you for the inspiration!!
Is there something else you can use instead of baking powder? You might not think much of them unless you’re cooking, but, both baking powder and baking soda are incredibly poisonous to dogs. Baking soda is dangerous for dogs because it’s a leavening agent. When mixed with an acidic substance and heat, baking soda and baking powder become extremely hazardous.
Hi Lori, according to my cousin (who is a vet) and google, baking soda and baking powder are only dangerous in large quantities. A large amount, in this case, is roughly one teaspoon per pound of body weight. Using 1/2 teaspoon (divided by 24 treats) is more than safe!
Hello. Looking to make these but is there a substitute for the milk? Can I use water, or is that not recommended? Thank you.
You can use water!
Anyone making this recipe or others with peanut butter, please make sure your peanut butter doesn’t contain Xylitol!
‘Xylitol, a sweetener used in many foods, including peanut butter, yogurt, toothpaste and chewing gum, is safe for humans but potentially deadly for dogs. If ingested, it can cause seizures, liver failure and death, warned one animal hospital, which called xylitol “extremely toxic” to dogs’
You said ” I think’ to roll 1 inch thick. that seems thick to me. Did I misunderstand the directions.
My dog loves these, we adopted her a month ago, and she loves These! Thank you so much for Sharing!
That is awesome! Congrats on the new addition!
Do I need to add the honey?
I would recommend it for flavor. However, you can try without and see if your dog will still eat them!
Well known food critic Brody LeDawg reports “Two paws up for this gourmet delight. Highly recommended for the discerning pup.”
I love these! How cute. As I was reading your story, I laughed. At 17 i was driving a 1980 Caddy, coupe DeVille-17.5 feet to be exact, lol. Then I saw a Pic of Brody! I have 3 cockers as well. They LOVE their PB. Thanks again.
Do you recommend placing the peanut butter on the cookies even if they’re not being eaten yet? I wanted to give them as gifts.
No, I would wait until they are being served…or not even worry about it at all. Sometimes I add the peanut butter for an extra treat and sometimes I skip it. Brody (our dog) loves them either way!
Just wanted to let you know I made these for my two pups birthdays and they were a smash! So easy to make, I will definitely keep these in the dog treat repertoire! Here’s my post about them, thanks again for the recipe!
http://pumpkinsandpeonies.com/2015/02/puppy-peanut-butter-cookie-sandwiches.html
My dough came out really stick so I wasn’t able to use the cookie cutter 🙁 other than that my dogs loved them.
Me too! You can add more flour
Hi these look amazing I know my prinnie will love these treats
One question Can you freeze them ?
Yes! Freeze them for up to 3 months!
delicious peanut butter sandwiched dog treat
Awww, look at handsome Brodyyy! What a spoiled pup. These are perfect, Jess!
Oh my goodness my pup Gus would go nuts over these. But is it weird that I really want some for myself…? Ok, it is, but I’m OK with it.
Aah! How cute! Our dogs are like our kids too and we have three. Kids not dogs. We love giving them homemade treats every now and then. No shame in spoiling them. Your dogis so cute. Love the hair!
These are gorgeous – esp for dog treats! Winston, Lucy, and Harley are peanut butter fans, too – they would love these! Thanks!
This is too funny because I’m working on a pet feature at my job that includes homemade dog food and treats. I’ve never actually made homemade treats before, but I think these would be the perfect things to try first! Super cute!